City of Carmel-by-the-Sea,
Record of Inventory of Historic Resources Appeals
CARMEL-BY-THE-SEA
HISTORIC RESOURCES BOARD
MEMBERS:
Julie Wendt, Chairperson
Paul Coss
Erik Dyar
Kay Holz
Erling Lagerholm
APPEALS: Considerations of Historic appeals of the City's determination to place existing residences on the City's Inventory of Historic Resources located in the Single Family Residential R-1 District. (unless otherwise noted)
TOTAL NUMBER OF APPEALS, as of April 2006: 25
APPEALS GRANTED: 11 (Including 1 by City Council, overturning HRB)
APPEALS DENIED: 11
APPEALS CONTINUED: 4
APPEALS NOT HEARD: 1
ON HISTORIC RESOURCES BOARD 17 APRIL 2006 AGENDA
Patrick Paw & Caroline Wong
N.E. Corner Casanova & 10th Av.
Resource Name: Fraser Hancock House
APPEAL DENIED
AYES: DYAR, COSS, HOLZ, LAGERHOLM, WENDT
NOES: NONE
Shatzi H. Joy
N.E. corner Casanova & 9th Av.
Resource Name: Herron Cottage & Tree House
APPEAL DENIED
AYES: COSS, DYAR, HOLZ, LAGERHOLM, WENDT
NOES: NONE
Margaret Suzuki
E/s San Carlos St. between 11th Av. and 12th Av.
Resource Name: Joseph Catherwood Cottage
APPEAL GRANTED
AYES: COSS, HOLZ, LAGERHOLM WENDT
NOES: DYAR
Peter Taormina
E/s Guadalupe St. between 5th Av. and 6th Av.
Resource Name: Allen Knight House
APPEAL GRANTED
AYES: COSS, DYAR, HOLZ, LAGERHOLM, WENDT
NOES: NONE
Diane M. Sena
E/s Lincoln St. between 7th Av. and 8th Av.
Resource Name: Alice Mechenstock House
APPEAL DENIED
AYES: COSS, HOLZ, WENDT
NOES: DYAR, LAGERHOLM
Jeffrey & Jennifer Svihus
W/s Junipero Av. between 10th Av. and 11th Av.
Resource Name: Turner House
APPEAL CONTINUED to June 19, 2006
ON HISTORIC RESOURCES BOARD MARCH 2006 AGENDA
James & Gail Finnegan
W/s Carmelo bet. 11th Av. & 12th Av.
Resource Name: Mary C. Chapin House
APPEAL GRANTED:
AYES: DYAR, COSS, HOLZ, LAGERHOLM, WENDT
NOES: NONE
Matthew & Maribeth Aguon
SE Corner Santa Rita & 2nd Av.
Resource Name: Alfred Rico Cottage
APPEAL GRANTED:
AYES: DYAR, HOLZ, LAGERHOLM, WENDT
NOES: COSS
Doreen Silva Trust
W/s Carpenter bet. 3rd Av. & 4th Av.
Resource Name: DeSabla Horse Barn
APPEAL DENIED:
AYES: COSS, DYAR, HOLZ, LAGEHOLM
NOES: NONE
ON HISTORIC RESOURCES BOARD FEBRUARY 2006 AGENDA
David & Audrey Hall
W/s Carmelo bet. 11th Av. & 12th Av.
Resource Name: E. P. Young Spec. House
APPEAL DENIED:
AYES: COSS, HOLZ, WENDT
NOES: LAGERHOLM
ABSENT: DYAR
Note: HALL'S APPEAL OF HRB'S DECISION TO CITY COUNCIL ON CITY COUNCIL 2 MAY 2006 AGENDA; APPEAL GRANTED BY CITY COUNCIL
Alfred Johnson
W/s San Antonio bet. Ocean & 4th Av.
Resource Name: Elizabeth McClung White House (Sand & Sea)
APPEAL DENIED:
AYES: COSS, HOLZ, LAGERHOLM, WENDT
NOES: NONE
ABSENT: DYAR
Deborah Storre
NW Corner Lincoln & 8th Av.
Resource Name: J.M. Storrow House
APPEAL GRANTED:
AYES: COSS, LAGERHOLM, WENDT
NOES: HOLZ
ABSENT: DYAR
Joe & Julie Villarreal
N/s 2nd bet. Guadalupe St. & Santa Rita St.
Resource Name: C.D. Osbourne House
APPEAL GRANTED:
AYES: COSS, HOLZ, LAGERHOLM
NOES: WENDT
ABSENT: DYAR
ON HISTORIC RESOURCES BOARD JANUARY 2006 AGENDA
APPEAL: Consideration of an appeal of the City's issuance of a preliminary Determination of Ineligibility for listing on the City's Inventory of Historic Resources for an existing residence in the Single Family Residential (R-1) District.
Appellant: Carmel Preservation Foundation
W/s Lincoln bet. 9th Av. & 10th Av.
APPEAL DENIED:
AYES: DYAR, HOLZ, LAGERHOLM, WENDT
NOES: COSS
APPEAL: Consideration of a Historic Appeal of the City's determination to place an existing structure on the City's Inventory of Historic Resources located in the Central Commercial (CC) and Downtown Conservation (DC) Overlay Districts.
Appellant: Doris Rayne Trust
S/s Ocean bet. Lincoln & Dolores
Resource Name: Schweinger Building
APPEAL DENIED:
AYES: COSS, DYAR, HOLZ, LAGERHOLM, WENDT
NOES: NONE
Note: RAYNE APPEAL OF HRB'S DECISION TO CITY COUNCIL ON 4 APRIL 2006 AGENDA; AT 4 APRIL 2006 MEETING, IT WAS ANNOUNCED THAT THE APPELLANT HAD PULLED THE ITEM.
APPEAL: Consideration of a Historic appeal of the City's determination to place existing residence on the City's Inventory of Historic Resources located in the Single Family Residential R-1 District.
Norman & Eleanor Moscow
W/s Camino Real bet. 11th & 12th
Resource Name: Wild Cottage
APPEAL DENIED:
AYES: DYAR, HOLZ, WENDT
NOES: LOSS, LAGERHOLM
APPEAL: Consideration of an Historic appeal of the City's determination to place 4 existing residence on the City's Inventory of Historic Resources as an Historic District located in the Single Family Residential (R-1) and Beach and Riparian Overlay (BR) Districts
Appellant: Kim, Johnson, Liskin
W/s San Antonio bet. Ocean & 4th Av.
APPEAL NOT HEARD DUE TO A POLICY DECISION EARLIER IN THE MEETING TO REMOVE ALL POST-1940 PROPERTIES FROM THE INVENTORY OF HISTORIC RESOURCES PENDING COMPLETION OF AN UPDATE OF THE HISTORIC CONTEXT STATEMENT.
ON HISTORIC RESOURCES BOARD DECEMBER 2005 AGENDA
Carolyn Ahrens
W/s Carpenter bet. 3rd Av. & 4th Av
Resource Name: Benjamin H. Cory Garage Apartment
APPEAL GRANTED:
AYES: DYAR, COSS, LAGERHOLM, WENDT
NOES: NONE
ABSENT: HOLZ
Ruth & Alan Scott
N/s 8th bet. Junipero Av. & Torres St.
Resource Name: George Seideneck House
APPEAL GRANTED:
AYES: DYAR, COSS, LAGERHOLM, WENDT
NOES: NONE
ABSENT: HOLZ
Joseph & Susan Raphel
SW San Antonio & 11th Av.
APPEAL GRANTED:
AYES: DYAR, LAGERHOLM, WENDT
NOES: COSS
ABSENT: HOLZ
ON HISTORIC RESOURCES BOARD NOVEMBER 2005 AGENDA
William & Mildren Daniel
N/s 13th bet. San Antonio & Carmelo
APPEAL DENIED:
AYES: DYAR, HOLZ, LAGERHOLM, WENDT
NOES: NONE
ABSENT: COSS
Elaine Larkin
S/s Mt. View Av. bet. Santa Rita St. & Santa Fe St.
Resource Name: "The Press in the Forest"
APPEAL GRANTED:
AYES: DYAR, HOLZ, LAGERHOLM, WENDT
NOES: NONE
ABSENT: COSS
William Doolitttle
E/s Casanova bet. 7th Av. & 8th Av.
Resource Name: Daniel T. Fisk House
APPEAL CONTINUED FOR 90 DAYS; YET NOT ON HRB'S FEBRUARY, MARCH, APRIL 2006 AGENDAS.
Eldana Eggleston
W/s Camino Real bet. 7th Av. & 8th Av.
Resource Name: Dr. Amelia Gates Cottage
APPEAL DENIED:
AYES: DYAR, HOLZ, WENDT
NOES: LAGERHOLM
ABSENT: COSS
ON HISTORIC RESOURCES BOARD OCTOBER 2005 AGENDA
APPEAL: Consideration of an Historic Appeal of the City's determination to place an existing structure on the City's Inventory of Historic Resources located in the Central Commercial (CC) and Downtown Conservation (DC) Overlay Districts.
Appellant: Paul Laub
N.E. Corner Dolores St. & Ocean Av.
Resource Name: Bank of Carmel
APPEAL CONTINUED AT THE REQUEST OF APPELLANT.
No comments:
Post a Comment