UPDATE: Appeals of Historic Inventory Resources

  
Mary Young Hunter House
(N.E. Corner Ocean Av. & Torres St.)


City of Carmel-by-the-Sea,
Record of Inventory of Historic Resources Appeals

CARMEL-BY-THE-SEA
HISTORIC RESOURCES BOARD

MEMBERS:
Julie Wendt, Chairperson
Paul Coss
Erik Dyar
Kay Holz
Erling Lagerholm


APPEALS: Considerations of Historic appeals of the City's determination to place existing residences on the City's Inventory of Historic Resources located in the Single Family Residential R-1 District.

TOTAL NUMBER OF APPEALS, as of May 2006: 29
APPEALS GRANTED: 12 (Including 1 by City Council, overturning HRB)
APPEALS DENIED: 12
APPEALS CONTINUED: 6
APPEALS NOT HEARD: 1

ON HISTORIC RESOURCES BOARD 22 MAY 2006 AGENDA

Dolores Schmidt
N.E. Corner Ocean Av. & Torres St.
Resource Name: Mary Young Hunter House
APPEAL DENIED
AYES: COSS, DYAR, HOLZ
NOES: LAGERHOLM
ABSENT: WENDT

John Wagner
W/s Camino Real Between Ocean Av. & 4th Av.
Resource Name: Dorothy MacDonald Cottage
APPEAL GRANTED
AYES: HOLZ, LANGERHOLM
NOES: DYAR
RECUSAL: COSS
ABSENT: WENDT

Mission St. Properties
W/s Mission between 4th Av. & 5th Av.
Resource Name: Joe McEldowney House
APPEAL CONTINUED

Sigrid Banks
E/s Lincoln St. between 13th Av. & Santa Lucia Av.
Resource Name: Laumeister House
APPEAL CONTINUED
AYES: COSS, DYAR, LAGERHOLM
RECUSAL: HOLZ
ABSENT: WENDT



Carmel-by-the-Sea
City Council Meeting
Regular Meeting
Tuesday, May 2, 2006, 4:30 P.M.

VIII. PUBLIC HEARINGS
Consideration of an appeal of the Historic Resources Board’s decision to deny a request to remove a property located on the west side of Carmelo, between Eleventh and Twelfth Avenues from the city’s inventory of historic resources. The appellant and property owner is David Hall.

David Hall
W/s Carmelo St. between 11th Av. & 12th Av.
Resource Name: E.P. Young Spec. House
APPEAL GRANTED
AYES: BETHEL, CUNNINGHAM, HAZDOVAC & McCLOUD
NOES: NONE
ABSENT: ROSE
ABSTAIN: NONE

Consideration of remanding a decision of the Historic Resources Board that removed properties from the Historic Resources Inventory developed between 1940 and 1956 with direction to the board to reverse its decision based on new information and analysis.
AYES: BETHEL, CUNNINGHAM, HAZDOVAC & McCLOUD
NOES: NONE
ABSENT: ROSE
ABSTAIN: NONE



Carmel-by-the-Sea
City Council Agenda
Regular Meeting
Tuesday, June 6, 2006, 4:30 P.M.

VIII. Public Hearings

B. Consideration of an appeal of the Historic Resources Board’s decisionto deny a request to remove a property located in the Single Family Residential (R-1) District from the City’s Inventory of Historic Resources
(Norman and Eleanor Moscow, W/s Camino Real be. 11th & 12th, Blk R, Lot 11 & 13, APN: 010-274-005).
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: GRANT APPEAL AND OVERTURN HRB's DECISION

C. Consideration of an appeal of the Historic Resources Board’s decision to deny a request to remove a property located in the Single Family Residential (R-1) District from the City’s Inventory of Historic Resources
(Eldana Eggleston, W/s Camino Real be. 7th & 8th, Blk N, Lot 11, APN: 010-265-004).
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: DENY APPEAL AND UPHOLD HRB's DECISION

E. Consideration of an appeal of the Historic Resources Board’s decision to deny a request to remove a property located in the Central Commercial (CC) and Downtown Conservation Overlay (DC) Districts from the City’s Inventory of Historic Resources
(Doris M. Rayne Trust, S/s Ocean bet. Lincoln & Dolores).
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: DENY APPEAL AND UPHOLD HRB's DECISION

F. Consideration of an appeal of a decision of the Historic Resources Board placing a commercial structure, known as the Palo Alto Savings and Loan building, on the Carmel Inventory of Historic Resources. The building is located on the southeast corner of Seventh Avenue and Dolores Street. The property owner is the Pacific Grove Land Company. The appellant and project designer is John Mandurrago.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Uphold the Historic Resources Board’s determination that the Palo Alto Savings building is eligible for listing on Carmel’s Inventory of Historic Resources.