Resource Name: Robert A. Norton House
Location: Monte Verde St. 5 N.W. 4th Av.
Distinction: APPEAL DENIED
UPDATE: HISTORIC APPEALS TO THE HISTORIC RESOURCES BOARD
(November 2005 – March 2007)
APPEALS GRANTED: 37
APPEALS DENIED: 19
APPEALS DISMISSED: 14
APPEALS OF A PRELMINARY DETERMINATION OF INELIGIBILITY:
GRANTED: 1
DENIED: 3
TOTAL NUMBER OF APPEALS: 74
NUMBER ADDED TO REGISTER FROM INVENTORY: 1
HISTORIC APPEALS TO THE HISTORIC RESOURCES BOARD (February & March 2007)
(Name of Property Owner, Physical Location, Resource Name, APPEAL GRANTED or DENIED)
CITY OF CARMEL-BY-THE-SEA
HISTORIC RESOURCES BOARD
Regular Meeting
19 March 2007
BOARD MEMBERS:
ERIK DYAR, CHAIRPERSON
ELINOR LAIOLO (Absent)
ERLING LAGERHOLM
JULIE WENDT
EXTRORDINARY BUSINESS
Swearing in of new Board Member Don Wiese.
Consideration of a request to place historic properties on the City’s Register of Historic Resource.
Rob Rossi
N.W. Corner Ocean Av. & Casanova
Resource Name: C. Halstead Yates Cottages
APPROVED
Consideration of an appeal of the City’s determination to place an existing residence located in the Single Family Residential (R-1) District on the City’s Inventory of Historic Resources.
Workman Brothers Development Co.
E/s Casanova between 7th Av. & 8th Av.
Resource Name: John Hancock House
APPEAL GRANTED
CITY OF CARMEL-BY-THE-SEA
HISTORIC RESOURCES BOARD
Regular Meeting
26 February 2007
Considerations of appeals of the City’s determination to place existing residences located in the Single Family Residential (R-1) District on the City’s Inventory of Historic Resources.
San Carlos, LLP
NW Cor. San Carlos & 12th
Resource Name: Cooper House
APPEAL GRANTED
Xavier Urpi
W/s Monte Verde bet. 2nd & 4th (Monte Verde St. 5 N.W. 4th Av.)
Resource Name: Robert A. Norton House
APPEAL DENIED
Evalee Harrison
E/s Junipero bet. 2nd & 3rd (Junipero Av. 4 S.E. 2nd Av.)
Resource Name: Dr. C. L. Trawin Cabin
APPEAL GRANTED
Jesse & Carol Kahn
S/s 8th bet. Junipero & Torres (8th Av 2 S.E. Junipero Av.)
Resource Name: Kahn House
APPEAL GRANTED
Tim Allen
E/s Lopez bet. 2nd & 4th (Lopez 7 S.E. 2nd Av.)
Resource Name: Mary E. Collins Cottage
APPEAL GRANTED
NOTE: For a List of Historic Appeals to the Historic Resources Board, November 2005 –September 2006, please click on Post of Tuesday, October 10, 2006 and Updated List, click on Post of Wednesday, January 24, 2007.
2 comments:
Every time the HRB meets and removes a residence from the Historic Inventory is a further indictment of the city council and their absolute incompetance. In such a hurry to claim political victory for a certified LCP, they obviously didn't claim equal responsibility for a thorough review prior to submission to the coastal commission. One even wonders whether any of the council members bothered to read the document.
They fuss and expend too much public time over one mills act contract, even using decreased revenue as a means of denial. If they didn't know enough to have a reasonable and accurate inventory, then how is it possible for any of them, including our less than stellar city manager, to know the intricacies of the mills act?
It will be interesting to see if there are other appeals after the 200 are notified of their historic status recorded on their respective deeds.
Incompetent people do not become competent people overnight. It will soon be time to clean house in 2008 if Carmelites are serious about government and our town.
Post a Comment