LIST of Historic Appeals to the HISTORIC RESOURCES BOARD

LIST OF HISTORIC APPEALS TO THE HISTORIC RESOURCES BOARD
November 2005 – September 2006
(Name of Property Owner, Physical Location, Resource Name, APPEAL GRANTED or DENIED)
Consideration of Historic appeals of the City's determinations to place existing residences on the City's Inventory of Historic Resources located in the Single Family Residential R-1 District. (unless otherwise stated)

HISTORIC RESOURCES BOARD 21 NOVEMBER 2005 MEETING MINUTES
William & Mildred Daniel
N/s 13th Avenue bet. San Antonio & Carmelo
Resource Name: Grace McGowan Cook House
APPEAL DENIED

Elaine Larkin
S/s Mt. View Av. bet. Santa Rita & Santa Fe Streets
Resource Name: “Press in the Forest”
APPEAL GRANTED

Eldana Eggleston
W/s Camino Real bet. 7th & 8th Avenues
Resource Name: Dr. Amelia Gates Cottage
APPEAL DENIED

HISTORIC RESOURCES BOARD 19 DECEMBER 2005 MEETING MINUTES
Consideration of an appeal of a Preliminary Determination of Ineligibility for the Carmel Inventory of Historic Resources and recommendation’s to the Planning Commission on the adequacy of an Environmental Impact Report for the demolition of a commercial structure and the construction of a mixed-use project in the Service Commercial (SC) District
John Mandurrago
SE Corner Dolores & 7th Avenue
Resource Name: Palo Alto Savings And Loan
APPEAL GRANTED

Carolyn Ahrens
W/s Carpenter bet. 3rd & 4th Avenues
APPEAL GRANTED

Ruth & Alan Scott
N/s 8th bet. Junipero Avenue & Torres St.
APPEAL GRANTED

Joseph & Susan Raphel
SW Corner San Antonio & 13th Av.
APPEAL GRANTED

HISTORIC RESOURCES BOARD 23 JANUARY 2006 MEETING MINUTES
Consideration of an appeal of the City's issuance of a preliminary Determination of Ineligibility for listing on the City's Inventory of Historic Resources for an existing residence in the Single Family Residential (R-1) District.
Appellant: Carmel Preservation Foundation
W/s Lincoln bet. 9th & 10th Avenues
APPEAL DENIED

Consideration of an appeal of the City’s determination to place an existing residence on the City’s Inventory of Historic Resources located in the Central Commercial (CC) and Downtown Conservation Overlay (DC) Districts.
Doris Rayne Trust
S/s Ocean between Lincoln & Dolores Streets
APPEAL DENIED

Norman & Eleanor Moscow
W/s Camino Real bet. 11th & 12th
Resource Name: Wild Cottage
APPEAL DENIED

HISTORIC RESOURCES BOARD 27 FEBRUARY 2006 MEETING MINUTES
David & Audrey Hall
W/s Carmelo bet. 11th & 12th Av.
Resource Name: E. P. Young Spec. House
APPEAL DENIED

Alfred Johnson
W/s San Antonio bet. Ocean & 4th Av.
Resource Name: E. M. White House #4
APPEAL DENIED

Deborah Storre
NW Corner Lincoln & 8th Av.
Resource Name: J. M. Storrow House
APPEAL GRANTED

Joe & Julie Villarreal
N/s 2nd bet. Guadalupe & Santa Rita
Resource Name: C. D. Osbourne House
APPEAL GRANTED

HISTORIC RESOURCES BOARD 20 MARCH 2006 MEETING MINUTES
James & Gail Finnegan
W/s Carmelo bet. 11th & 12th Avs.
Resource Name: Mary C. Chapin House
APPEAL GRANTED

Matthew & Maribeth Aguon
SE Corner Santa Rita & 2nd
Resource Name: Alfred Rico Cottage
APPEAL GRANTED

Doreen Silva Trust
W/s Carpenter bet. 3rd & 4th Avs.
Resource Name: DeSabla Horse Barn
APPEAL DENIED

HISTORIC RESOURCES BOARD 17 APRIL 2006 MEETING MINUTES
Patrick Paw & Caroline Wong
NE Corner Casanova & 10th Avenue
Resource Name: Fraser Hancock House
APPEAL DENIED

Shatzi H. Joy
NE Corner Casanova & 9th Avenue
Resource Name: Herron Cottage & Tree House
APPEAL DENIED

Margaret Suzuki
E/s San Carlos between 11th Avenue & 12th Avenue
Resource Name: Joseph Catherwood Cottage
APPEAL GRANTED

Peter Taormina
E/s Guadalupe St. between 5th & 6th Avenues
Resource Name: Allen Knight House
APPEAL GRANTED

Diane M. Sena
E/s Lincoln St. between 7th & 8th Avenues
Resource Name: Alice Meckenstock House
APPEAL DENIED

HISTORIC RESOURCES BOARD 22 MAY 2006 MEETING MINUTES
Dolores Schmidt
NE Corner Ocean Avenue & Torres St.
Resource Name: Mary Young Hunter House
APPEAL DENIED

John Wagner
W/s Camino Real between Ocean Avenue & 4th Avenue
APPEAL GRANTED

HISTORIC RESOURCES BOARD 19 JUNE 2006 MEETING MINUTES
Jeffery & Jennifer Svihus
W/s Junipero Avenue between 10th & 11th Avenues
Resource Name: Turner House
APPEAL GRANTED

Sigrid Banks
E/s Lincoln St. between 13th Avenue & Santa Lucia Avenue
Resource Name: Laumeister House
APPEAL GRANTED

Belinda Ray
S/s Santa Lucia Avenue between Dolores St. & Mission St.
Resource Name: Betty Buckley House
APPEAL GRANTED

William Doolittle
E/s Casanova between 7th & 8th Avenues
Resource Name: Daniel T. Fiske House
APPEAL GRANTED

HISTORIC RESOURCES BOARD 26 JUNE 2006 MEETING MINUTES
Tony & Judy Tollner
NE Corner Santa Rita St. & 6th Avenue
Resource Name: George C. Bestor House
APPEAL GRANTED

Sydney Roussel
W/s Carmelo between 9th & 10th Avenues
Resource Name: Roussel Residence
APPEAL DENIED

Carl & Jan Cox
E/s Casanova between 9th & 10th Avenues
Resource Name: Artie Bowen House
APPEAL DENIED

HISTORIC RESOURCES BOARD 17 JULY 2006 MEETING MINUTES
ADMINISTRATION
Consideration of an action by the Board to dismiss the following appeal applications:
Mary W. Ives
NE Corner San Carlos & St. Lucia
Resource Name: Rev. Gardner House
APPEAL DISMISSED

Winston Boyer
NE Corner Camino Real & 13th
Resource Name: Robert W. Covington House
APPEAL NOT DISMISSED

Carolyn Priestley Martin
E/s Santa Fe bet. Mt. View & 8th
Resource Name: Jacob W. Wright House (2)
APPEAL DISMISSED

Emily Leonardi
E/s Santa Rita bet. 5th & 6th
Resource Name: Raymond Meeks House
APPEAL DISMISSED

APPEALS
Consideration of an appeal of the City’s determination to place existing structures located in the Residential and/or Limited Commercial (RC) District on the City’s Inventory of Historic Resources.

Mission St. Properties
W/s Mission bet. 4th & 5th
Resource Name: Joe McEldowney House
APPEAL GRANTED

Consideration of an appeal of the City’s issuance of a Preliminary Determination of Ineligibility for listing on the City’s Inventory of Historic Resources for an existing residence located in the Single Family Residential (R-1) District.
Carmel Preservation Foundation (Appellant)
Tony & Jane Diamond
SE Corner of Santa Rita & 3rd
Resource Name: Grey Gables/Culbertson House
APPEAL DENIED

HISTORIC RESOURCES BOARD 21 AUGUST 2006 MEETING MINUTES
ADMINISTRATION
Consideration of an action by the Board to dismiss the following appeal applications:

Charlene Mathews Walters Tr
W/s Monte Verde bet. Ocean & 4th
Resource Name: Abbie McDow House
APPEAL DISMISSED

Bank of America Tr
SW Camino Real & 11th
Resource Name: Robert Allen Griffin House
APPEAL DISMISSED

Christopher Schaepe & Jennie Chiu Tr
SW Casanova & 11th
Resource Name: Reginald Markham House
APPEAL DISMISSED

Dennis Levett
SE Cor. Dolores & 4th
Resource Name: Frederick Bigland Apartments
APPEAL DISMISSED

Edward Ybarro
W/s Torres bet. 1st & 2nd
Resource Name: F. A. Watson House
APPEAL DISMISSED

C.W. Freedman
NE Cor. Casanova & 7th
Resource Name: D. W. Johnson House
APPEAL DISMISSED

Caryl Lockett Miller
N/s Ocean bet. Santa Fe & Santa Rita
Resource Name: W. O. Swain Cottage #3
Common Name: Ocean House
APPEAL DISMISSED

Michael Castillo
SW Cor. Ocean & Forest
Resource Name: Florence Lockwood Studio/House
APPEAL DISMISSED

Sylvia Breiholz
NW Cor. Monte Verde & 10th
Resource Name: Guest House
APPEAL DISMISSED

APPEALS
Consideration of appeals of the City’s determination to place existing residences located in the Single Family Residential (R-1) District on the City’s Inventory of Historic Resources.

Maureen Chodosh
NW Cor. San Carlos & 10th
Resource Name: Albert E. Otey House
Staff Recommendation: Grant Appeal
APPEAL GRANTED

Donald & Elizabeth Mathews
E/s Santa Rita bet. 1st & 2nd
Resource Name: Ben Figuroa House
Staff Recommendation: Amend DPR to include Carmel stone wall and chimney on the City’s Inventory of Historic Resources, but remove the historic designation of the primary residence.
APPEAL GRANTED

Faustino & Ines Seoane
W/s Torres bet. 10th & 11th
Resource Name: ”Carmel Type” Cottage
APPEAL GRANTED

James & Marjorie Barrow
E/s Monte Verde bet. 7th & 8th
Resource Name: Caroline P. Webster House
APPEAL DENIED

HISTORIC RESOURCES BOARD 18 SEPTEMBER 2006 MEETING MINUTES
James & Kathleen Smart
S/s 7th Avenue between Forest Road & City Line
Resource Name: Mr. & Mrs. J. B. Lukes
APPEAL DENIED

Rod & Sibyl Johnson
W/s Guadalupe St. between 2nd & 3rd Avenues
Resource Name: Irene Fleischer Guest House
APPEAL GRANTED

Lada Kratky
E/s Casanova between 12th & 13th Avenues
Resource Name: Mrs. Ester Jones House
APPEAL GRANTED

John Clayton
NW Corner Carmelo & 13th Avenue
Resource Name: William E. Clayton House
APPEAL GRANTED

Barry Long
SW Corner Torres St. & 2nd Avenue
Resource Name: Morsony House
APPEAL GRANTED